Taiwan’s partnership with Somaliland highlights a people-centric soft power strategy that contrasts sharply with China’s approach in Africa, reinforcing democratic legitimacy, development and international recognition.
This editorial by the Taipei Times, discusses the “soft power” diplomacy between Taiwan and Somaliland, two self-governing states seeking greater international recognition.
Key points:
-
Taiwan Avenue: Taiwan funded a significant portion of a road upgrade in Somaliland, which was named “Taiwan Avenue.” This highlights the collaboration and strengthens ties between the two.
-
Contrasting Models: The editorial contrasts Taiwan’s development-focused approach in Somaliland with China’s “self-serving” investment model in Africa through the Belt and Road Initiative.
-
Mutual Recognition: Somaliland and Taiwan have established representative offices in each other’s capitals, using the names “Taiwan” and “Republic of Somaliland,” reinforcing their individual legitimacy despite lacking formal diplomatic ties.
-
People-Centric Cooperation: Taiwan’s cooperation model emphasizes “knowledge transfer and capacity building” with the aim to create a model in Somaliland that can “win more friends in east Africa.”
-
Beacon of Democracy: Somaliland is portrayed as a “beacon of democracy” while the “authoritarian bloc” (presumably China) is seen as suppressing Taiwan and Somaliland’s international participation.
-
Israel’s Recognition: Israel’s formal recognition of Somaliland as an independent state is a major boost to Somaliland’s bid for more international support.
Overall Argument:
The editorial argues that the soft power approach of Taiwan, exemplified by its relationship with Somaliland, is slowly building recognition of desired narratives. This is further aided by Israel’s recognition of Somaliland, highlighting the benefits of mutually beneficial international relations. The collaboration demonstrates that Taiwan and China are distinct entities.
The complete piece is as follows:
EDITORIAL: Soft Power with Somaliland
There is a modern roadway stretching from central Hargeisa, the capital of Somaliland in the Horn of Africa, to the partially recognized state’s Egal International Airport. Emblazoned on a gold plaque marking the road’s inauguration in July last year, just below the flags of Somaliland and the Republic of China (ROC), is the road’s official name: “Taiwan Avenue.”
The first phase of construction of the upgraded road, with new sidewalks and a modern drainage system to reduce flooding, was 70 percent funded by Taipei, which contributed US$1.85 million. That is a relatively modest sum for the effect on international perception, and reinforces the contrasts between Taiwan and China.
The plaque itself speaks volumes, in the wording, the adjacent flags, the message it conveys and the underlying policy behind the collaboration. Both Somaliland and Taiwan are self-governing states struggling to secure international recognition. Their mutual association and strengthening, albeit informal, of diplomatic ties, is one way to reinforce their attempt to find a solution to the predicament. That the name “Taiwan” was used instead of the “Republic of China,” especially when juxtaposed with the ROC flag, is a measure of the recognition that the ROC is Taiwan, and that it is not the People’s Republic of China.
On a continent where Beijing is making diplomatic inroads into many nations with its Belt and Road Initiative, Taiwan’s collaborations and investment within Somaliland contrasts the Taiwanese model of seeking to provide benefit and development for locals compared with China’s largely self-serving model of investment in Africa.
An article published on July 17 by the Somaliland Standard news agency, “Taiwan and Somaliland inaugurate ‘Taiwan Avenue’ in Hargeisa, strengthening bilateral ties,” said the event was “part of a broader context of Taiwan’s diplomatic strategy in Africa, where it seeks to expand its influence and challenge dubbed China’s ‘One China’ policy.” That is part of a “unique relationship” with Taiwan, including the opening of representative offices in each other’s capitals, it said.
The representative offices use the official names “Taiwan” and the “Republic of Somaliland.” Despite the lack of formal diplomatic ties, the names reinforce the message of individual legitimacy.
Taiwan Representative to Somaliland Allen Lou (羅震華) has said that Taiwan’s model of cooperation is “people-centric” and focuses on “knowledge transfer and capacity building,” and that ultimately the hope is to create a model in Somaliland to “win more friends in east Africa.”
President William Lai (賴清德) met with Somaliland Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Abdirahman Dahir Adam Bakal in July last year following the signing of an agreement between the nations on coast guard cooperation. Lai talked about the need to deepen bilateral ties and fulfill the strategic goal of a “non-red” Somaliland shoreline. He called Somaliland “the beacon of democracy in the Horn of Africa,” and that the “authoritarian bloc” continues to ramp up suppression of Taiwan’s and Somaliland’s international participation.
Taipei’s policy contrasts authoritarian states and democracies, and in particular those that are seeking legitimacy internationally. That these contrasts exist is further evidence that Taiwan and China are separate entities, with distinct governments, even if that is not reflected in international recognition.
On today’s page, analyst Michele Maresca (“Benefits of Israel’s pivot in Africa”) writes that Taiwan’s partnership with Somaliland has helped with the African nation’s aspirations to bolster international recognition. That was given a major boost by Israel’s formal recognition of Somaliland as an “independent and sovereign state” on Dec. 27 last year, making Israel the first UN member to do so. That recognition is a stepping stone in Somaliland’s bid for more international support: It not only provides broader legitimacy, but it now has a champion in Israel.
Soft power works slowly, sometimes imperceptibly, but over time lays the foundations for the evolution of circumstances by forming recognition of desired narratives. It is helped when the application of the soft power is implemented in good faith and for mutual benefit. Israel’s recognition of Somaliland was a significant boost to Hargeisa’s cause. Hopefully the application of soft power will continue to aid Taiwan’s.
